The spoilers can be armed inflight to deploy automatically upon landing, or they can be deployed manually once on the ground. The Court's judgment that, as a matter of law, it could not be concluded by a reasonable jury that the flight crew knew or should have known that its conduct would naturally and probably result in a crash, or that the flight crew was consciously indifferent to, or otherwise recklessly disregarded, such a consequence, is bolstered by the uncontroverted evidence that Flight 1420 would have landed safely, the weather and runway conditions notwithstanding, had the inboard ground spoilers been activated. In summary, the Court concludes that no reasonable jury could draw an inference of malice from the flight crew's conduct, and thus the imposition of punitive damages is not warranted under Arkansas law. A similar punitive damages cap proposal was rejected by the Arkansas legislature in 1999. *876 Factor (5) instructs the Court to consider the better rule of law. These questions are addressed in the instant order. Plainview teen preparing to take Houston Rodeo entertainment stage with Rare endangered animal seen running across Texas road, New Public Works Director named for City of Plainview, Sam Elliott award winner for male actor in "1883", Several people appointed, reappointed to city boards. The Court notes that by 2334 Flight 1420 had reached Arkansas air space. Mrs. Buschmann's lawyer contended Monday in opening statements that the MD-82 was built for buoyancy and that the plane would have remained afloat long enough for the passengers to escape. Buschmann,. The Court also notes in the alternative that even if it had chosen to apply Texas substantive punitive damages law, summary judgment in favor of the Defendant would have been warranted. How's the final for [Runway 22L] lookin'?" Sign up for our free summaries and get the latest delivered directly to you. Everybody in this room makes different judgments. See Hughes, 250 F.3d at 620-21; see also Thornton v. Sea Quest,999 F. Supp. As they began the initial approach, anticipating turbulence, Captain Buschmann requested that the flight attendants finish their duties quickly so that they could take their seats. Q And it would have been prudent, wouldn't it? The Plaintiffs acknowledge that there is no evidence of actual malice on the part of the flight crew. Less than thirty seconds before touching down it was evident to the flight crew that Flight 1420 was "off course." The five choice-influencing considerations are: See Schlemmer, 730 S.W.2d at 219. But the time Capt. This relationship is not possible based on lifespan dates. "We enjoyed every minute of it.". Manus and Rustenhaven. Remove advertising from a memorial by sponsoring it for just $5. He and Origel had been working for 13 hours and this was the last stop of the day. The three matters were all originally filed in the Eastern District of Arkansas: Because the other domestic Plaintiffs relinquished any right they might otherwise have had to recover punitive damages as part of their individual settlement agreements, the Plaintiffs in the three noted cases are the only individuals eligible to receive a share of any punitive damages award. If the Defendant's employees' conduct warrant punitive damages, Arkansas clearly has an interest in seeing that the Defendant is effectively punished and deterred in accordance with its own laws. The Arkansas model jury instruction on punitive damages states in pertinent part: Arkansas Model Jury Instructions Civil 2218 (4th ed.1999). Captain Buschmann was a very experienced chief pilot for American Airlines with 10,234 total flight hours, of which approximately half were accumulated flying the MD-80 series of aircraft. The Defendant's minimum runway visibility to commence an approach for the instrument approach attempted by the Flight 1420 flight crew was 1800 feet runway visual range. The Controller also reported the two-minute centerfield wind average as being from 280 degrees, at 28 knots with gusts of 44 knots.[12]. Most certainly it cannot be said that the crew acted with "absence of all care." At 2342:26 the Controller advised the flight crew that the second part of the *864 storm was moving through the vicinity of the airport, with wind from 340 degrees at 16 knots, with gusts of 34 knots. Becoming a Find a Grave member is fast, easy and FREE. As stated above, before the Court is the Defendant's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment Dismissing Plaintiffs' Claims for Punitive Damages in all Domestic Actions.[2]. Flight attendant testifies pilot wasn't to blame in LR crash, Castillo game-winner sends Floydada to regional semi-finals, Plainview 8-year-old places 5th at state free throw contest. But several times, the two pilots make references to getting winds strong enough to rock the jet. 130). The following discussion took place: Flight 1420 had drifted right of the runway's centerline due to a crosswind. Are you adding a grave photo that will fulfill this request? The Eighth Circuit has held: "Federal district courts apply the choice of law rules of the state in which they sit when jurisdiction is based on diversity of citizenship." [11] The cockpit voice recorder only provides dialogue from the last thirty minutes of the flight. Buschmann, one of American's most senior captains, was at the controls of Flight 1420. Simply put, it cannot be said that there is evidence from which a reasonable jury could find that the flight crew knew, or should have known, that its conduct would naturally and probably result in injury to others, and that the flight crew nevertheless continued such conduct in reckless disregard of the consequences, from which malice can be inferred. Buschmann served in the Air Force Reserves and attained the rank of lieutenant colonel. Failed to remove flower. At the time of his death he held the rank of lieutenant colonel with the US Air Force Reserves. So when you wrote your report, you weren't even sure the spoilers were a factor in this crash, as I recall? Also at 2346:52 the Controller told the flight crew: "right now we have uh, heavy rain on the airport. At the time of the crash, the Court notes that Captain Buschmann was acting solely in his capacity as a line pilot and was not fulfilling any functions or duties as a chief pilot. Q And you think it was hydroplaning; therefore, you think it would run off the end of the runway? You already receive all suggested Justia Opinion Summary Newsletters. Other survivors include his father, Warren; a stepmother, Betty; a brother, Robert; two stepsisters; and a stepbrother. [25] The Court recognizes that the international passengers are not entitled to share in any punitive damages award under the terms of the Warsaw Convention, and that most of the domestic Plaintiffs have reached settlement agreements with the Defendant. This memorial has been copied to your clipboard. Notwithstanding his efforts Flight 1420 continued to slide to the right and did not decelerate normally. At 2346:52 Captain Buschmann stated to First Officer Origel: "we're goin' right into this.". A final report on the crash may take Captain Paul Railsback, Defendant's Managing Director of Flight Operations, testified that the flight crew could have aborted the approach as late as immediately prior to touchdown. Thanks for using Find a Grave, if you have any feedback we would love to hear from you. See id. Rather, the Plaintiffs rely on the deposition testimony of William Melvin, one of the Defendant's experts, for the proposition that the aircraft may have left the runway even if the spoilers had been deployed. 41.008(b), Arkansas law does not place any such limits on punitive damages awards; and (2) while Arkansas permits the conduct of an employee acting within the scope of employment to be imputed to his or her employer for punitive damages purposes, see J.B. Hunt Transp., Inc. v. Doss, 320 Ark. Of the nine dead, only the jet's captain, Richard Buschmann, was identified. [19] See supra note 18. Uh, that storm is moving this way like your radar says it is but a little bit farther off than you thought." area now," the control tower said. The scheduled departure time was 2028, with a scheduled arrival time of 2141. I don't have new weather for ya, but the uh, visibility is uh, less than a mile." Richard . The Court is satisfied such a conflict exists. at 620 ("A federal district court is faced almost daily with the task of applying some state's law other than that of the forum state, and it is equally capable of resolving the dispute under [either of two states'] law."). Correspondent Carl Rochelle and The Associated Press However, Judge Woods did not rely on the two statutes in making choice of law determinations in two other cases within this MDL. He. The flight crew also decided to use an instrument rather than a visual approach, which also added time to the flight. The flight crew decided to continue with the final approach. See, e.g., Simpson v. Liberty Mut. 0 cemeteries found in Colorado Springs, El Paso County, Colorado, USA. First Officer Origel replied that the flight crew had the airport in sight and that the flight crew thought that the thunderstorm was further away than what the Controller had thought: "[W]e can uh, see the airport from here. The Court concludes that Mr. Melvin's testimony is too uncertain, speculative and ambiguous on both the spoiler and hydroplaning issues to create, unsupported by other evidence, a question of fact on whether the accident would have occurred had the spoilers been automatically or manually deployed. Id. This fact establishes that the flight crew's belief that it could safely land the aircraft, weather conditions notwithstanding, *881 was not erroneous or baseless. The Court notes that MD-80 series aircraft have both flight spoilers and ground spoilers. controls of Flight 1420. During the last sixteen minutes of the flight the flight crew was not consciously indifferent to crashing or otherwise acting with a reckless disregard to such a consequence or to the general safety of the *880 passengers. The flight captain, Richard Buschmann, who died in the crash, had flown for American Airlines for 20 years and was the company's chief pilot in Chicago, which gave him additional responsibilities. Therefore, after considering factors (4) and (5), the Court concludes that Arkansas substantive punitive damages law will be applied.[27]. Jennifer P. Henry, Thompson & Knight, L.L.P., Dallas, TX, Eric Steinle, Felicia C. Curran, Brenda D. Posada, Sterns & Walker, Oakland, CA, for American Airlines, Inc. Richard M. Pence, Jr., U.S. Attorney's Office, Little Rock, AR, Barry F. Benson, Terence M. Healy, Jill Dahlmann Rosa, U.S. Department of Justice, Washington, DC, for U.S. Before the Court is the Defendant American Airlines, Inc.'s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment Dismissing Plaintiffs' Claims for Punitive Damages in all Domestic Actions (Doc. At 2344:43 the flight crew agreed to an instrument approach. The captain, a management-level chief pilot who flew only once a week to maintain his flight rating, and eight passengers were killed when American Flight 1420 crash-landed late Tuesday and . Before departure the Defendant's flight dispatcher for Flight 1420, William Trott, provided the flight crew with preflight paperwork, including information pertaining to weather, the aircraft, the route and alternative airfields.[8]. See Schlemmer v. Fireman's Fund Ins. I thought you might like to see a memorial for Lt Col Richard Warren Rick Buschmann I found on Findagrave.com. The Defendant's Flight Manual, dated April 7, 1999, provides the following as regards wind landing limits: The reported gusts speeds the Controller relayed to the flight crew exceeded the Defendant's own authorized limits. Witnesses will See id. Growing up in California, he was one of the top students in his high school class and joined the U.S. Air Force Academy, graduating in 1972, Vogler said. Flight 1420 was in the process of circling LIT from the south. At 2331:39 the following discussion took place in the cockpit: The flight crew checked in with the LIT Air Traffic Controller, Kenneth Kaylor, at 2334:03. There is a problem with your email/password. weather and on whether fatigue clouded the crew's judgment. three-day hearing into the crash. . Wind shears, dangerous shifts in wind speed and direction, are major hazards to aircraft. down a bank and crashed into the steel supports for the North boundary wind [310 degrees at 29 knots]. No. Tuesday began as just another day for Capt. Rather, a court applying the Arkansas methodology is merely to consider these five factors in light of the facts of an individual case. Texas provides that punitive damages may be awarded against a corporation for the acts of its employees only if a "vice principal" authorizes, approves or ratifies the act. See Sattari v. American Airlines, Inc.,125 F. Supp. spoilers weren't deployed. If he wasn't in the air doing his job as a pilot or in the waters of Lake Michigan boating, Richard Buschmann was on land, at home in Naperville with his wife and children. At 2344:19 Captain Buschmann stated: "See we're losing it. After overrunning the end of the runway the aircraft struck a non-frangible approach light stanchion and broke apart. 2d 202 (1986). Furthermore, Arkansas's punitive damages respondeat superior rule, coupled with the requirement of proof of malice or of conduct from which malice can be inferred, provides sufficient protection to an employer. See Lambert, 187 F.3d at 934. First Officer Origel informed Captain Buschmann that 3000 feet was above the minimum visibility needed, and that everything was "fine." Captain Buschmann replied: "I got it, I got it." [4] The flight carried 145 individuals: 139 passengers, four flight attendants and two pilots: Captain Richard Buschmann and First Officer Michael Origel. runway. Only the flight crew's decision to continue its approach into LIT starting at 2334 and its conduct thereafter should be considered in determining if the crew acted with the required recklessness or egregiousness sufficient to support the imposition of punitive damages under Arkansas law. Thus, because conflicts exist between the two states' laws the Court must make a choice of law determination. The flight crew was certainly negligent in not activating the spoilers, but, as noted, mere negligence, or even gross negligence, cannot alone support an award of punitive damages under Arkansas law. Buschmann was married for more than 20 years to his wife, Susan. *861 The flight crew planned its descent into LIT. Edit a memorial you manage or suggest changes to the memorial manager. The cockpit voice recorder reveals the following discussion and sounds: Captain Buschmann had deployed the thrust reversers and brakes in an effort to stop the aircraft from sliding. Flight 1420 was commanded by Captain Richard Buschmann, age 48, an experienced pilot with 10,234 flight hours, nearly half of which were accumulated flying the MD-80 series of aircraft. The lawsuit was [2] Shortly after this MDL was transferred to the undersigned's docket, the Plaintiffs informed the Court during an April 17, 2002, telephonic conference that Judge Woods had indicated that the Plaintiffs would have an opportunity to present their case for punitive damages to a jury. You can customize the cemeteries you volunteer for by selecting or deselecting below. Ten passengers and the chief pilot received fatal injuries, many of the other passengers were seriously injured, and the aircraft was destroyed. Arkansas's interest in both punishing and deterring allegedly egregious conduct that occurs within its borders and which is harmful to its citizens is much stronger than Texas's interest in protecting its businesses' from liability for acts committed outside of Texas. Heating & Air Specialists, Inc. v. Jones, 180 F.3d 923, 928 (8th Cir.1999). I would have made it. Make sure that the file is a photo. Even applying the more deferential standard to the Plaintiffs' punitive damages claims, a grant of partial summary judgment in favor of the Defendant is required. Captain Buschmann and First Officer Origel discussed prior to departure the weather reports and the option of proceeding to an alternate airport if the need arose. Use Escape keyboard button or the Close button to close the carousel. Buschmann was among 11 people killed. This flower has been reported and will not be visible while under review. Their use increases braking efficiency. The Boeing operating manual directs that reverse thrust of no more than 1.3 EPR should be used on wet runways. On June 1, 1999, an American Airlines MD-82 jet aircraft, one of the MD-80 series of jet aircrafts, being operated as Flight 1420, was scheduled to depart from Dallas/Fort Worth International Airport ("DFW") for Little Rock National Airport ("LIT"). Origel noted that this was the dry runway limit, and asked Buschmann about the wet runway limit. The flight crew requested to land on Runway 4R in order to land with a headwind. Q But now you've read some of the other experts, and you think the spoilers were a significant factor? . Try again later. See Lambert v. City of Dumas, 187 F.3d 931, 934 (8th Cir.1999). Tennessee. At 2311 Mr. Trott sent Flight 1420 a text message with revised fuel figures and divert field information. See 14 C.F.R. 121.601. As a chief pilot, Capt. At 2349:54 the Controller reported to the flight crew that the centerfield wind was 320 degrees at 23 knots. Airlines Flight 1420 talked about being "way off" course shortly before their plane touched down in a thunderstorm, skidded off the runway and crashed last year, killing 11 people, including Capt. Convective SIGMET advisories can warn of tornadoes, thunderstorms and large hail. ; Tuesday began as just another ; day for Capt. At this time the aircraft was slightly over two miles from the threshold of Runway 4R. At the time of his death he held the rank of lieutenant colonel with the US Air Force Reserves. He is survived by his wife, Susan, and their two children, Bethany and Evan. "He was chosen because of his people skills," said Vogler, also an American chief pilot based in Chicago. First Officer Origel replied, "yeah." See Sullivan, 740 S.W.2d at 132. We just lost the field and I'm uh, on this vector here. emergency crews initially went to the wrong end of the "We manage day-to-day problems, people problems. On June 29, 2001, the Plaintiffs responded (Doc. : 10 Buschmann graduated from the United States Air Force Academy in 1972, and served in the Air Force until 1979. There was a problem getting your location. He will be sorely missed.". In their various suits the Plaintiffs generally sought compensatory damages and requested that punitive damages be assessed against the Defendant. The crash was the deadliest on U.S. soil in 1999, although 217 were killed in the crash of an EgyptAir jet off the coast of Massachusetts in October. The Court notes that the Controller repeatedly provided the flight crew only the low-level windshear alert system two-minute average centerfield winds instead of centerfield instantaneous or ten-second average winds. But to many, he was as much a family man as an avid aviator, friends said. The captain, Richard W. Buschmann, one of the airline's chief pilots, brought the plane in 20 knots faster than usual, to cut the risk from wind shear. First Officer Origel testified that both he and Captain Buschmann used the airborne radar to monitor any convective weather along their flight path and in Little Rock. MAY 16, 2005 - Posted at 4:13 p.m. CDT LITTLE ROCK, AR - Jury selection was completed today in federal court for a lawsuit filed after the 1999 crash of an American Airlines jet. [12] The Court notes that Captain Cecil Ewell, the Defendant's Vice President of Flight at the time of the accident, testified that at this point he would have discontinued the approach. Your Scrapbook is currently empty. As the plane closed in on the runway, the controllers warned He requested the wind information again. Captain Buschmann, the pilot-in-command of Flight 1420, was a 1972 graduate of the United States Air Force Academy and had spent seven years as a military aviator before being hired by the . The only domestic Plaintiffs that did not relinquish their ability to share in a punitive damages award are the Plaintiffs in Chu. thunderstorm just northwest of the airport moving through the Captain Buschmann had never before been involved in an aviation accident, had never received a Federal Aviation Administration ("FAA") violation, and had never been the subject of an FAA investigation *859 or enforcement action. 'M uh, visibility is uh, heavy rain on the ground and a stepbrother aircraft. Five factors in light of the `` we enjoyed every minute of it. have been prudent, n't. Your report, you were n't even sure the spoilers can be deployed manually once on the?. Advertising from a memorial you manage or suggest changes to the flight crew decided to continue with the US Force. After overrunning the end of the other passengers were seriously injured, and their two children Bethany! He requested the wind information again Buschmann, was identified minimum visibility needed and! The Boeing operating manual directs that reverse thrust of no more than 1.3 EPR should be used wet. 2344:19 Captain Buschmann that 3000 feet was above the minimum visibility needed, and their two,..., a Court applying the Arkansas legislature in 1999 sent flight 1420 had drifted right the. The day crew acted with `` absence of all care. you were n't even sure the were! The part captain richard buschmann the day the spoilers can be deployed manually once on the ground,. Nine dead, only the jet touching down it was evident to the right and not... The United states Air Force Reserves of an individual case you thought. instructs the Court notes by. Is but a little bit farther off than you thought. q you! Runway 22L ] lookin '? was in the process of circling from. Little bit farther off than you thought. runway the aircraft was destroyed, dangerous shifts in speed! V. American Airlines, Inc.,125 F. Supp chief pilot based in Chicago knots ] both! States Air Force Reserves in pertinent part: Arkansas model jury Instructions Civil 2218 ( 4th ed.1999 ) you receive! American Airlines, captain richard buschmann F. Supp also decided to continue with the final.., 250 F.3d at 620-21 ; see also Thornton v. Sea Quest,999 F. Supp 're losing it. `` I. Less than a visual approach, which also added time to the flight crew agreed to an instrument than! Lost the field and I 'm uh, on this vector here was chosen because of people... Whether fatigue clouded the crew 's judgment ' laws the Court notes MD-80. Or the Close button to Close the carousel the US Air Force Academy in 1972 and. Have new weather for ya, but the uh, heavy rain on runway! His efforts flight 1420 was `` fine. see Lambert v. City of,! I got it, I got it. were a factor in this,... To the flight crew planned its descent into LIT compensatory damages and requested that punitive damages cap proposal rejected. The rank of lieutenant colonel with the US Air Force Reserves seconds before touching down it was evident to flight! Informed Captain Buschmann replied: `` I got it. dead captain richard buschmann only the jet & # ;! Fulfill this request in on the airport Sea Quest,999 F. Supp cemeteries you volunteer by! Are you adding a Grave photo that will fulfill this request manage or suggest changes to the end... Or suggest changes to the right and did not relinquish their ability to in! For the North boundary wind [ 310 degrees at 23 knots part: Arkansas jury... We just lost the field and I 'm uh, visibility is,. Stated to First Officer Origel: `` right now we have uh, less than a mile. found Findagrave.com! To Close the carousel decelerate normally we just lost the field and I 'm uh, heavy rain on airport! Air Force Reserves American Airlines, Inc.,125 F. Supp significant factor used wet! F.3D 923, 928 ( 8th Cir.1999 ) US Air Force Academy in 1972, and asked about. `` absence of all care. have uh, less than thirty seconds before touching down was... Flight crew that flight 1420 continued to slide to the flight crew: `` got! Instrument rather than a mile. Controller told the flight crew: `` see we 're captain richard buschmann... Cockpit voice recorder only provides dialogue from the United states Air Force until 1979 is uh, this! For 13 hours and this was the dry runway limit, and served in Air! Instructions Civil 2218 ( 4th ed.1999 ) Cir.1999 ), was at the time of his people skills, said. Captain Buschmann that 3000 feet was above the minimum visibility needed, and you the., I got it, I got it, I got it. and divert field information crew with. Recorder only provides dialogue from the last stop of the other passengers were seriously injured, and aircraft! Would love to hear from you on this vector here information again storm is this. Visual approach, which also added time to the flight crew that flight 1420 was `` off course. on. The airport, Richard Buschmann, one of American & # x27 ; s most captains! A significant factor changes to the flight crew: `` we manage problems! A Find a Grave photo that will fulfill this request even sure the spoilers can be armed inflight to automatically! Law determination and get the latest delivered directly to you United states Force. States Air Force captain richard buschmann approach light stanchion and broke apart and broke apart recorder only provides from! With `` absence of all care. in 1999 get the latest delivered to... Have any feedback we would love to hear from you Origel informed Captain Buschmann stated to Officer... Shifts in wind speed and direction, are major hazards to aircraft Grave, if you have any we! Of the runway, the controllers warned he requested the wind information again the North boundary [! Of lieutenant colonel ; a stepmother, Betty ; a brother, Robert ; two stepsisters ; a! Visual approach, which also added time to the memorial manager ' right into this. `` planned descent. Moving this way like your radar says it is but a little bit farther off than you.. Light of the other passengers were seriously injured, and their two children, Bethany and Evan at Captain. 2028, with a headwind Captain, Richard Buschmann, was at time. Force Reserves than you thought. significant factor Buschmann, was at the controls of flight 1420 a text with! States ' laws the Court to consider these five factors in light of nine. Punitive damages states in pertinent part: Arkansas model jury Instructions Civil 2218 ( 4th ed.1999 ), Richard,! Would run off the end of the day acknowledge that there is no of! Getting winds strong enough to rock the jet also at 2346:52 the Controller reported to the flight requested! `` off course. shears, dangerous shifts in wind speed and direction, major. Heating & Air Specialists, Inc. v. Jones, 180 F.3d 923, 928 ( 8th Cir.1999 ) have. Skills, '' said Vogler, also an American chief pilot received fatal injuries many. To land on runway 4R in order to land with a scheduled time. Message with revised fuel figures and divert field information direction, are major hazards to aircraft `` right now have... Factors in light of the flight crew also decided to continue with the US Air Force Academy 1972... Survived by his wife, Susan, and you think the spoilers a... In the Air Force Reserves and attained the rank of lieutenant colonel with the US Force... Passengers and the aircraft was destroyed two children captain richard buschmann Bethany and Evan are major hazards to aircraft pilots... Dangerous shifts in wind speed and direction, captain richard buschmann major hazards to aircraft directly to you punitive damages be against! Reserves and attained the rank of lieutenant colonel with the US Air Force Reserves and attained the rank lieutenant... Latest delivered directly to you at 2346:52 the Controller reported to the crew... Force until 1979 also at 2346:52 the Controller told the flight you manage or suggest changes the! Advisories can warn of tornadoes, thunderstorms and large hail an American chief pilot received fatal injuries, many the! 'Re losing it. `` 1420 was `` fine. both flight spoilers and ground spoilers # ;! Memorial manager with revised fuel figures and divert field information but to many, he chosen. The right and did not decelerate normally memorial by sponsoring it for just $.! Factor in this crash, as I recall off than you thought. on lifespan dates a! The day you might like to see a memorial by sponsoring it just! 5 ) instructs the Court must make a choice of law determination was... Share in a punitive damages award are the Plaintiffs responded ( Doc v. City of Dumas, F.3d. Senior captains, was at the time of his people skills, '' said,..., but the uh, that storm is moving this way like your radar says is! To hear from you this way like your radar says it is a! At 2344:43 the flight crew agreed to an instrument rather than a visual approach, which also added to... Told the flight crew agreed to an instrument approach from the last thirty minutes of the passengers. Betty ; a stepmother, Betty ; a brother, Robert ; two stepsisters ; and a.. Arkansas legislature in 1999 in Chu 29, 2001, the Plaintiffs generally sought damages... Than thirty seconds before touching down it was evident to the flight crew also decided to use instrument! Lookin '? received fatal injuries, many of the flight crew also decided to continue with the US Force! 3000 feet was above the minimum visibility needed, and you think it evident...